Tapes from the Darkside Tapes from the Darkside
  • Episodes
    Season 1 10 Season 2 3 Season 3 6 Season 4 5 Season 5 12 Season 6 3 Season 7 6 Season 8 3 Season 9 6 Season 10 8 Season 11 26 Season 12 7 All Episodes 109
  • Reviews
    All Reviews
    Rate on Apple Podcasts podcast player icon Rate on Apple Podcasts
    Rate on Spotify podcast player icon Rate on Spotify
    Rate on Podchaser podcast player icon Rate on Podchaser
  • Patreon
  • Merch
  • donate
  • Search
Search
April 28, 2025

Meet Our Friend: Morning Cup of Murder

Meet Our Friend: Morning Cup of Murder
Tapes from the Darkside
Meet Our Friend: Morning Cup of Murder
Your browser does not support the audio tag.

"If you like your coffee hot but your bones chilled..." Welcome to your home for all things Morning Cup of Murder Podcast.

https://morningcupofmurder.com/

Apple Podcasts podcast player logo Apple Podcasts Spotify podcast player logo Spotify iHeartRadio podcast player logo iHeartRadio PocketCasts podcast player logo PocketCasts Castbox podcast player logo Castbox Overcast podcast player logo Overcast Podcast Addict podcast player logo Podcast Addict Amazon Music podcast player logo Amazon Music Castro podcast player logo Castro Podchaser podcast player logo Podchaser RSS Feed podcast player logo RSS Feed
More
Apple Podcasts podcast player icon Apple Podcasts Apple Podcasts Spotify podcast player icon Spotify Spotify iHeartRadio podcast player icon iHeartRadio iHeartRadio PocketCasts podcast player icon PocketCasts PocketCasts Castbox podcast player icon Castbox Castbox Overcast podcast player icon Overcast Overcast Podcast Addict podcast player icon Podcast Addict Podcast Addict Amazon Music podcast player icon Amazon Music Amazon Music Castro podcast player icon Castro Castro Podchaser podcast player icon Podchaser Podchaser RSS Feed podcast player icon RSS Feed RSS Feed
More
  • Show Notes
  • Transcript

"If you like your coffee hot but your bones chilled..." Welcome to your home for all things Morning Cup of Murder Podcast.

https://morningcupofmurder.com/

 

Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/tapesfromthedarkside

Merch
https://merchfromthedarkside.com/

Leave us a Review (...it really helps!)
https://www.tapesfromthedarkside.com/rate/

Paypal / Venmo Donations
https://www.tapesfromthedarkside.com/paypal/

0:00 Today, I have something a little different for you, guys and gals, a podcast recommendation from one of our friends. The podcast is called Morning Cup of Murder. This is going to be perfect for those of you who maybe want to break from the full hour long deep dive episodes. Morning Cup of Murder has more bite sized episodes that are going to be good for your morning routine or just when you need a quick true crime fix. This show is bingeable and they have over two thousand episodes in their back catalog over forty million downloads. It's easy to understand why people keep coming back to the show. The host is Karina Beemesderfer and she's able to make each case compelling, whether it's well known or one you've never heard of. So I want to play it for you now. We've got a short clip for you from one of their episodes. If you like what you hear, just search for it wherever you get your podcasts.

0:56 There were two more murders fifteen miles away, at least fowls, telephones and electricity lines. Holy heavy weird lean described by one investigator as reminiscent of a weird morning murder. Not all cases can be wrapped up with a bow and confidence that justice has been served. On March third, nineteen eighty three, the bodies of a young man and a young woman were found on a ranch in Iowa. Though investigators were pretty confident they knew who killed the pair and why, the case lacks answers and above all justice for those who were killed. So if you like your coffee hot but your bones chilled, sit back and start your day with a morning cup of murder. On March third, nineteen eighty three, a ranch hand working at the Copper Dollar Ranch just northwest of Newton, Iowa, walked over to one of the on site trailers and made a horrific discovery.

1:54 Lying face down just outside and near the barn, covered in blood, was the body of a man wearing only his blue jeans, and inside the trailer was the brutalized body of what appeared to be a young woman, both of which had had wounds so significant it was impossible to identify the pair by sight alone. Though they had a pretty good idea of who the bodies belonged to, it would take a medical examiner, fingerprints, and dental records to know for sure, all of which confirmed that the male body belonged to the trailer's inhabitant, twenty year old Stephen Fisher, and the other was that of his seventeen year old girlfriend, Melissa Gregory. Their cause of death was a bludgeoning, so brutal. Police initially thought the couple had been shot, which is what rumor began circulating through the area until the medical examiner's reports cleared things up. Word traveled fast through Jasper County, and before police ever contacted them, Melissa's mother Ida and sister Lisa that they heard about the murdered couple on Copper Dollar Ranch on a local television news station, while her brother Scott found out through a friend's brother. The death of these two young people rocked this small town to its very core. No one had any clue why Stephen and Melissa were targets, at least not at first. Stephen and Melissa were well liked members of the community, but though they had been dating

3:25 for the last nine months, Stephen was still technically married to a woman named Teresa Subpino Fisher. Their marriage was a rocky one, filled with domestic disputes that involved not just the couple, but Teresa's father and brothers, as well, specifically her twin brother, Timothy Subppino, a man who admitted to visiting Stephen at his trailer at eleven pm on March second, making him the last known person to see the couple alive. Then there were the rumors that, in addition to raising quarter horses and Appalousa's, there was a drug trafficking operation taking place at Copper Dollar Ranch. Could that have had something to do with the murders. Jasper County Attorney Stephen Johnson would later acknowledge the known drug activity in the area, but told the press that based on the brutality of the murders, he believed that the deaths were quote up close and personal, likely some personal motive rather than a random attack. An FBI profiler given the case agreed, calling the murder of Stephen Fisher and Melissa Gregory a crime of passion. But though they followed dozens of potential leads, it seemed like everything headed straight to a dead end, so they went back to their primary suspect from the very beginning of the investigation, Teresa Subpino, Steven's estranged wife. While police continued to look into her whereabouts the night of the murders. On September fifteenth, two thousand and nine, an article appeared in the Newton Daily

4:57 News containing Teresa's announcement that she planned on writing a book featuring the facts, opinions, and theories about the unsolved murders of her husband and his girlfriend. She encouraged local residents to come forward with any information on the case and set up an email for them to contact. That same year, the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigations established a cold case unit, and amongst the one hundred and fifty listed cases they planned on working using the latest advancements in DNA technology was the double murder at Copper Dollar Ranch. Although the cold case unit's federal grant funding was completely exhausted by December of twenty eleven, the DCI continued to assign agents to these cold cases as new leads developed or more advances were made. Then, in November of twenty twelve, a man named John Halferdy was elected as Jasper County's new sheriff. That's when everything started to change between the sheriff's office, the DCI's determination, and the investigation by the true crime television show Coal Justice. On March third, twenty fourteen, exactly thirty one years after Stephen Fisher and Melissa Gregory were found dead at the ranch, a press conference was held in which it was announced that there had finally been an arrest in the case. Teresa's Subpino, now in her fifties, was in custody and had been charged with

6:29 two counts of first degree murder. She entered a plea of not guilty on March tenth, and remained in jail in lieu of a four hundred thousand dollars bond. Due to the pre tripublicity in Newton, the judge moved the trial to Waterloo and jury's selection began in February of twenty fifteen. Teresa's lawyers argued that there was no physical evidence tying her to the murders, no DNA and no fingerprints, Yet they did admit that she drove to the ranch with her brother the night before the bodies were found, looking for Stephen Fisher. Using that admission, prosecutors claimed that she beat her husband and Melissa to death in a fit of jealous rage over the affair. Countering the defense, brought forth the former owner of the Copper Dollar Ranch, who admitted in court that he was dealing drugs on the property at the time of the murders, stating their belief that the double murder was drug related rather than an act of aggression on their client's part. The owner, though reluctant, at first, told the jury that Stephen knew about the drug dealing for about a year, and claimed that he had been told at some point that Stephen was working with the police as a drug informant. He said he didn't believe it at the time, but on the day the bodies were discovered, police allegedly confirmed Stephen's status as an informant. After three weeks of back and forth, Teresa Seppino was acquitted by a black Hawk County jury on February twentieth, twenty fifteen, after five hours of deliberation.

8:04 She was free to walk away and filed a defamation lawsuit shortly thereafter against the county sheriff and the prosecutor. With that the case of who killed Stephen Fisher and Melissa Gregory was considered officially cleared by investigators, though they have said the doors opened for any new leads as they become available. The case remains at a stasis, meaning that all these decades later, the families and loved ones of the victims still sit waiting for answers and justice. Thank you for joining me in my morning cup of murder. Please join me again tomorrow to your what terrible thing happened on March fourth. Don't forget to rate and subscribe and let me know how you like it. If you want to help support the podcast, there's always Patreon or just sharing it with your true crime obsessed friends. And remember, stay safe.

Join the Email List
Email has been submitted.
By signing up, you agree to receive email from this podcast.
Please complete the reCAPTCHA verification

Listen On

Apple Podcasts podcast player badge
Spotify podcast player badge
iHeartRadio podcast player badge
PocketCasts podcast player badge
Castbox podcast player badge
Overcast podcast player badge
Podcast Addict podcast player badge
Amazon Music podcast player badge
Castro podcast player badge
Podchaser podcast player badge
RSS Feed podcast player badge

Featured Episodes

  • S5, Chapter 1: Exterminator
  • S11, Chapter 1: Bart and Krista Go Missing
  • S1, Chapter 1: Dylan Goes Missing

Recent Episodes

  • Trailer | The Dylan Redwine Files
  • S1, Chapter 1: Dylan Goes Missing
  • S1, Chapter 2: The Pictures
  • S1, Chapter 3: Dr. Phil Showdown
  • S1, Chapter 4: The Big Lie
  • S1, Chapter 5: Two Percent
  • S1, Chapter 6: There Goes the Haterhood
  • S1, Chapter 7: A Killer Profile
  • S1, Chapter 8: Justice for Dylan
  • See all →

Support On

Patreon badge
Paypal badge
Tapes from the Darkside Logo

Covering the dark side of humanity with a hauntingly tragic approach.

  • Episodes
  • About
  • Merch
  • Contact
  • Patreon
  • Rate
  • Donate
  • Reviews
  • Merch
  • donate
  • © T. Z. Borden 2024
  • Podcast Website by Podpage