S6, Chapter 2: House of Pain
How could otherwise seemingly normal parents...
Part 2-of-2.
"House of Pain"
How could otherwise seemingly normal parents subject their daughter to such prolonged and unimaginable torture? Let's search for an answer.
This full series is out now:
- The Girl Who Melted | Chapter 1
- House of Pain | Chapter 2
- AFTERSHOW | The Girl Who Melted w/ Dr. Kirk Honda
Support us on Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/tapesfromthedarkside
—
Follow on instagram for behind-the-scenes and updates.
@thedarksidepod
https://www.instagram.com/thedarksidepod/
Check out our side project: The True Crime Pod.
https://linktr.ee/thetruecrimepod
—
Music Credits:
20SIX Hundred
https://20sixhundred.bandcamp.com/
Augusta Treverorum
https://linktr.ee/trvrrm
—
Featured Promo: LOVE MURDER
A weekly true crime podcast about relationships gone fatally wrong. This show is all about seemingly normal people driven to terrible madness by passion and rage. How does someone go from sweet to psycho in the blink of an eye? Tune in to find out all the ways murder can give love a real bad name.
https://www.lovemurder.love/
—
For comments or corrections, please email:
tapesfromthedarksidepod@gmail.com
Patreon
https://www.patreon.com/tapesfromthedarkside
Merch
https://merchfromthedarkside.com/
Leave us a Review (...it really helps!)
https://www.tapesfromthedarkside.com/rate/
Paypal / Venmo Donations
https://www.tapesfromthedarkside.com/paypal/
0:05 Tapes from the Dark Side contains descriptions of violence and sexuality. Listener discretion is advised. Doctor Pickham was curious how long it had been since Lacy had actually seen a doctor. He was the one who tracked down doctor Donald Hope, who said he last saw Lacy for treatment in two thousand and two. Lacy would have been just seventeen years old. He says he did talk to Clay and Sheilaw on the phone in twenty ten, Lacy would have been twenty five, and doctor Hope recalls the conversation revolving around Lacy's autism diagnosis. He says her parents had a tough time accepting that Lacy had special needs. Lacy reportedly was refusing to leave the house, even to see a doctor. Doctor Hope says that he suggests did they force her, but as we now know, Sheila and Clay never followed through. Doctor Bickham sent request for medical records from all nearby hospitals and got no response. It appears that Lacy had not seen a doctor since she was seventeen. That's nineteen years. According to what I've read, Doctor Bickham might have been the one most affected by this case.
1:25 He said quote, the scene was sickening. I've seen some horrible things in my life, but nothing like this. I couldn't eat for a week and I cried for a week. In December of twenty twenty two, less than a year after Lacy's death, doctor Bickham resigned. More than anything else, I became obsessed with trying to find an answer to the question that I'm sure is also on your mind. How could a parent do this to their child? And seemingly normal parents at that The Fletchers were not hoarders, they didn't seem to have any obvious mental illness. They both held down jobs and had active social lives, Yet they neglected and abused their daughter in one of the most depraved ways imaginable. I read whispers that Sheila Fletcher had a Facebook page, and I wanted to review it, but appears she has deleted it and I couldn't find any screen captures. One report from the Daily Mail says that Sheila had written on her Facebook wall after Lacy's death quote mom and Dad love you so much, with a link to the details of the memorial service.
2:35 And although Sheila's Facebook account had disappeared, I did discover some traces of her online profile. For one, I found she was an active member of a group called the Slaughter Civic Club. It seems to be a volunteer group and Slaughter that helps put on small town events like Christmas parades, fall festivals, etc. Sheila appears in a number of pictures on the group facebook page. October twenty eighteen. She's smiling standing next to a woman holding a candle. The caption and the prize winner at Tonight's monthly meeting is a net presenting the prize is Sheila Fletcher. September twenty eighteen. She's standing behind three of her peers, another wide eyed smile and her arms stretched open embracing them. The caption It's Slaughterfest time. This is just a look back and all the support and love shared. Love y'all third times a charm hashtag shared the Love Slaughterfest.
3:36 One of the only pictures Clay appears in is from February of twenty eighteen. Sheila and Clay sat at a folding table draped with a white disposable tablecloth. They're sitting next to six friends. Sheila has her hand on the woman's shoulder sitting in adjacent to her they're both smiling. December twenty seventeen, Sheila wears a red Christmas dress, the collar decorated with holiday tree. Sheila looks happy and during all this time, her daughter Lacy sitting at home dying a slow, painful, undignified death. On May second, twenty and twenty two, a grand jury of twelve indicated Sheila and Clay Fletcher on charges of second degree murder, and a warrant was issued for their arrest. See what happens now. They're going to be arrested, and I think the sheriff is better in a position to explain what's going to happen at the other The warrants have been cut. The judge will sign them shortly and they will be arrested this afternoon and we placed into the East Bullish out of Parish prison. Will we be arrested. I'm not one hundred percent sware that the specific location, but they will be arrested this afternoon. Well, maybe allowed to turn themselves in.
4:56 I believe you guys are going to work this. We are discussing what their lawyer of them to turn themselves in, but they will be arrested this afternoon to Sheriff's office initially investigated this case in January, and the conditions that she was found was just unappromivable. I mean, you don't treat anybody or any animals like that, and aring a better position to explain that to you if they feel like they want to explain it to you right now. But something had you done, and we all got together, we all stood on the same platform, and when we're all here now, when we got a conviction, I've got an indictment for secondary murder. That's exactly right. I mean, it was horrific. As I said earlier today, I think it was nothing short of horrific and sickening. I know that the corner can speak a little more about that, but the one thing that I want to speak about what the district attorney said is that we all collectively work together to reach the point that we're at now. This is a this is a case that is rare, but today I think that everything was done correctly by every member of this team, and we successfully reached a conviction that we believe is going to bring justice for license situations. Cause of dance stem from severe matterical neglect, which led to chronic manutrition, acute starvation, the immobility, the cubitus, auser formation I steel my elitis which is bone infection, which led a
6:27 finalance of sepsis back to raemia flood forth not for cause of the Clay and Sheila were each held on three hundred thousand dollars bond. They bonded out of jail, which was not cheap as you can imagine in the state of Louisiana. Bond is said at right around twelve percent, which means they each paid out of pockets a nonrefundable thirty six thousand dollars until their trial date, which as of this recording has not yet arrived. Sheila and Clay Fletcher will continue to live as free individuals, but justice is coming. The district attorney said he will not accept any plea deals in this case. Quote on a murder, you have to have intent. Did they want to kill her? I want to say, yeah, they wanted to kill her. He goes on to say, it's a justice for Lacy. Nobody needs to be treated this way. On June nineteenth, two and twenty two, both Clay and Sheila pled not guilty, which means the case will go to trial in that date was initially set for February six, twenty twenty three, which was delayed.
7:44 The new date is set for June nineteenth, two thousand and twenty three. I have been in contact with the state regarding the nine phone call that Sheila made on the night of her daughter's death, which is pending release after the trial. When that day comes, I will post that nine one one phone call and hopefully also the video interview with Sheila and Clay that was conducted by police. I have some personal thoughts about this case that I'd like to share with you, theory on how this unimaginable situation might have developed. But before we do that, we'll take a quick break. Stay with us today.
8:31 Instead of a boring ad, I want to share with you what I think is an awesome true crime podcast. It's made by my friends Jesse Pray and Andy Cassette. They're the host of a weekly show that tells stories about relationships, love, and well murder. They focus on ordinary people who are driven to commit acts of brutality all in the name of so called love. I appreciate their in depth discussions in all so that they get right to the facts of the case. There is some humor, but in my opinion, it's tasteful and not overbearing. So do me a favor, go and give their show a listen. It's called Love Murder and is available on the iHeart app, Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcasts. That's it.
9:24 Back to the show. What is it about cases like that of Lacy Fletcher that so fascinates us? It's a question I often ask myself. In the genre of fiction horror, I can tell myself that it's not real, but in true crime, the fact that it is real is exactly what draws us to these stories. So I'll pose the question to you, dear listener, why do you listen to these stories? Is it for entertainment? Have you ever asked yourself? Are we sacrificing the tragedy of others for a quick dopamine hit. Of course, I'd like to think that there's something more than that, perhaps innate desire or drive to try and comprehend this seemingly incomprehensible. But maybe that's my own delusion, or maybe it's just wishful thinking. What are my true motives in my obsessive research into these cases? One uncomfortable thing that I've found is that in this story, like with many other true crime stories, there's an obvious villain, the Fletcher parents. What they did to their daughter represents pure evil, and there's an undeniable attraction to that feeling of righteous
10:54 indignation that boils over when I think of what they did to their daughter and only child. Not all judgment is bad. In fact, it can have incredible utility. We have to judge people in situations to navigate our way through life. But if I'm being honest, the way I feel towards Clay and Sheila has at times felt more like hatred than judgment, And I can't quite explain it, but there's something else inside of me that pushes back against that feeling, against that black and white way of thinking. Perhaps it's my conscience reminding me of the mistakes I've made, the people I've hurt. I don't know now. To be clear, I've never neglected or abused anyone in the way that the Fletcher parents abused and neglected their daughter, not even close.
11:52 But when I start to set aside the judgment and the hatred, I'm left with an emotion that feels much more honest and raw. And that's what I think I might call pity. You might call it compassion. And to make it clear, I'm not trying to morally grandstand here or tell you how you should feel. I also won't pretend to be able to explain how this situation came to be. I myself still cannot comprehend the depths of depravity that the human soul must exist in to be capable of neglecting another human being to the point of death, let alone your own child. But if I were asked to propose a theory, it might go something like this. There was some pivotal event that led to the beginning of Lacy being neglected. I can't tell you exactly what that was, but after some period of time, this neglect began to feel normalized in the eyes of her parents. A bedsore or a pressure ulcer can begin to form in just two to hours of a person not being moved, and if Sheila and Clay did not have any medical training, they might not have known that they would need to be continuously moving the Lacy to prevent her from forming these bed sores. Now, how it got to the point that it did, I have no idea, but What I do know is that part of the human condition is that we start to become accustomed
13:26 to things that initially seem unbearable. Have you ever been in a room with an absolutely disgusting smell, but after you've been in that room for maybe thirty minutes to an hour, or maybe even four or five hours, you can't really smell it anymore. I think that might be part of the key to understanding this. But I also think there had to be moments when Clay and Sheila realized they were neglecting their daughter to the point of severe medical abuse. I mean, there is no ignoring the fact that she was literally sitting in a pile of urine and feces, and these moments when reality broke through to them, I think that's when the extreme guilt and shame began to kick in.
14:13 And we'll come back to the shame in the second because I think that is actually one of the most important keys in understanding what happened. We know that there was one time when Sheila and Clay try to call a doctor to get help for Lacey, and I would say there had to have been at least a handful of times when they confronted Lacy and trying to convince her to go see a doctor, but their own delusions caused them to balk. The paradox is this, their refusal to accept that Lacy had a severe developmental disability created the very conditions for that disability to intensify and spiral out of control.
14:58 For whatever reason, they refused to accept that Lacy had Asperger syndrome, and they refused to accept that she could no longer make healthy decisions for herself. And unfortunately, that refusal meant they decided to let Lacy rot instead of getting her help. Being a parent is a huge responsibility, and taking care of a child, I think we can all agree as one of the most important jobs in the world. Neglecting your own child goes against our instincts as parents. Now I'm not a parent, but I know this being a son of two parents, and my parents were not perfect, and when they've fallen short, I've seen the pain on their faces. Even though Clay and Sheila were in denial, deep down, I think that they both resented themselves for what they were doing to their daughter. Again, this is only a theory, but my best guess is that Clay and Sheila were both struggling with their own mental health issues. In my hypothesis is that this internalized self hatred eventually turned outward and they began to resent their own daughter for the situation they had put themselves in. When a person struggling with mental health, it can be difficult to manage negative emotions and feelings, and I think this subconscious resentment they felt towards Lacy caused the neglect to intensify. In this I think was like pouring
16:32 gasoline on a fire. It's hard to imagine the level of delusion in which Clay and Sheila lived, being that they both were not schizophrenic. They both held down good paying jobs, they maintained a well kept house, and had active social lives. But if there was any event that might be able to shatter the delusion, I think it might have been the death of Lacy. Only time will tell if the delusion has been shattered. But if it has been and they are now living back in reality where they realize that they actually killed their own daughter, I'd think that fate might be worse than death.
17:18 Facing life in prison their only daughter dead, universally hated by the world. I imagine living in a world like that would not be dissimilar to living in hell. If there is such a thing, Sheila and Clay Fletcher will have to pay the legal price for the crimes. And whether there is a next life, one thing is for sure, the consequences of their actions will reverberate karmically long after their worldly existence comes to an end. Now, assuming that some of my presumptions are correct, I'm going to ask something of you, dear listener, that may seem uncouth or perhaps even defensive, which I can understand. You have just heard Lacy's story for the very first time and are likely still trying to find a way to wrap your head around the unimaginable pain and suffering that she experienced. But maybe in a couple of days, maybe a couple of weeks or months, I would ask you to reflect back on Lacy's story, and if you are the praying type, I would ask you to join me in a prayer not just for the soul of Lacey Ellen Fletcher, may she rest in peace, but also for the souls of Sheila Fletcher and Clay Fletcher. Yeah, I had what would you have? I would
18:48 have called the people. I don't have a char I wouldn't have had a chars. We have an obligation to each other humans. I'm telling Matt to live like God wants you to live. And you said that the Fletcher's attended church. Yeah, yeah, it was community. Yes, she said this is they come. Yes. Never never dreamed that anything like that was going on. She was an alderman, you know. And I mean she looked in clay. I mean that they were, you know, well like people.
19:37 What do you think should happen? Now? They don't. They don't have to pay for what I mean whatever, the you know, the law of the land is you know. I just I heard the other day that they was indicted for their second degree murder. What's sad fall? And how do you feel about them? Personally? They're stio humans. Sometimes we make bad mistakes. I'm t Z and I want to thank you for listening to Tapes from the Dark Side. A big thank you to everyone who supports us on Patreon. You guys make this show possible. If you like to support the show, you can do so at patreon dot com. Slash Tapes from the dark Side join at any level from one dollar to fifteen dollars. There's a number of different rewards that we offer their exclusive merch that you can only get from being a patron, Tapes from the Dark Side, stickers, enamel pins that have our tape and skull logo, and other fun stuff. You
21:11 can try out any tier, You can move up and down different tiers, cancel anytime. There's really no risk involved in Your support truly helps the show grow and improve. Our newest five dollars members are Robin Holiday, Gina Oybunko, Kendra Yates, Songbird, Lisa McKay hold Me, I'm Scary, Alis North, Brent Eldridge, E M. Jonathan Cox, Kayla Downing, Jackson Hardy, Melissa Palman, Crystal Nicola Chesterman, Karen Bennett, abbyt Smith, Ashley Warren, Michelle Masher, Tricia Chapman, James Johnson, Dana Lewis, Stacy wins It, Sarah M. Taylor, Justin Seacrest, Kelly Austin, Bill Ding, I like that one, Alex Chouman, Richardson, Frank Nancy word Weaver, mel Loves to Knit, Alison Ward Includis eight ninety seven, R M E. R. R. Sherry Ramos, Mandy Paquin, Andrew v, Alex Fishler, Patty Tiffany Murray and Emily Robinson. Our newest nine dollars members are Violet Ross, Jamie Baker, Stephanie Brown, Janie Doria,
22:49 and Teresa Wolan. And a most sincere expression of my gratitude for our fifteen dollars producer level members. I really can't tell you how much I appreciate your generosity Greg b Christy Ramcher, Jase LeVay, Erica Walters, Joel Simonson, Cherry Sly, Angela mf Alexis Kathleen and our newest producers Margaret Kolia Winston, Naomi Garcia, Christy Reese, Amber Catlett and Olivia Schmidt. If I mispronounce anyone's name, please message me on Patreon or send me an email and let me know. Credit for editing help with today's episode to Darren Wood. As always, a huge thank you to our musical contributors. Our main theme is brought to you by twenty six hundred and original music composed by Augusta Trevorum.
23:52 All of those links can be found in our show notes, as well as links to our social media Follow us on Instagram at the dark Side Pod, in Facebook dot com, slash tapes from the Dark Side until next time, try to enjoy the daylight
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeartRadio
PocketCasts
Castbox
Overcast
Podcast Addict
Amazon Music
Castro
Podchaser
RSS Feed